In their latest analysis, Sports Illustrated identified five 2024 NFL Draft picks most likely to be a bust in the AFC. Among the players highlighted, the spotlight was cast on Amarius Mims, an offensive tackle from Georgia Bulldogs drafted by the Cincinnati Bengals with the 18th overall pick. SI labeled him as potentially the biggest bust in this draft class, despite his impressive physical attributes standing at 6’8″ and weighing 340 pounds.
Mims has shown prowess in both pass protection and run blocking, overpowering defenders easily. However, red flags from Mims’ collegiate career could impact his transition to the NFL. With limited experience, starting only eight games in college, and a history of injuries, doubts arise about his ability to withstand the demands of an NFL season. At the 2024 combine, Mims’ Athleticism Score ranked 16th best among offensive tackles tested. The Bengals view Mims as a high-risk, high-reward player, betting on his potential to develop into an All-Pro talent.
While analysts like Bucky Brooks and Lance Zierlein praise Mims’ size and athletic ability and highlight his high upside, their main concern revolves around his past injuries. Overcoming these health issues and adjusting quickly to the professional level will be crucial for Mims to solidify the Bengals’ offensive line and improve their performance. However, with Sports Illustrated’s concerns and challenges highlighted in this article, Mims may face difficulties in meeting the high expectations placed upon him as he tries to make a name for himself in the NFL world.